Surprise as Mario
North Star as Luigi
Galaxy as Wario
Buttons as Waluigi
Heart Throb as Princess Peach
Lofty as Princess Daisy
Ribbon as Rosalina
Truly as Pauline
Baby Half Note as Toad
Baby Shady as Toadette
Gusty as Toadsworth
Baby Lofty as Starlow
Grogar as Bowser
Bray as Bowser Jr.
Wind Whistler as Birdo
Whizzer as Yoshi
I feel like Majesty fits the whole “god” thing better- if you only use the cartoon’s stuff then I guess Twilight, but also she was horrifically nerfed for the show- going based solely on show lore, maybe Meghan, or the Moochick? I think I Ribbon being the strongest of the unicorns?
What if the Princess Ponies were used for the Princesses? None of those horses are any good, though- they are better than Baby Lickety-Split, but a dead horse is better than that one.