@Aelvir
Yet I never see the appeal with less 80% of them. And believe me, I already rewatched all of them. Some are better than I thought, I’ll give you that.
@Background Pony #F484
Castle Sweet Castle, Tanks for the Memories, Appleoosa’s Most Wanted, Slice of Life, Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep, Canterlot Boutique, Rarity Investigates!, Crusaders of the Lost Mark, Scare Master, The Mane Attraction, The Crystalling, Applejack’s Day Off, The Times They Are a Changeling, Top Bolt, To Where and Back Again, All Bottled Up, A Royal Problem, The Perfect Pear, The Parent Map, The Beak Up Break Down, The Mean 6, A Matter of Principals, A Rockhoof and a Hard Place, Sounds of Silence, Frenemies, Student Counsel, Between Dark and Dawn, and The Last Laugh are terrible?
Rotten Tomatoes puts MLP: FiM at 74%, and Bluey at 69% (both audience scores with no official critic reviews to compare on either), overall.
Though to be fair, for MLP individual season reviews had fewer than 50 audience member voters each and only Season 1 was reviewed by 10 critics for 100%. Season 6 and 8 were considered awful by the voting fans, with Season 7 being considered mediocre. (Again, that’s across fewer than 50 voting reviewers). The other seasons scored above 70%.
Of Bluey’s 3 seasons, audience rating fluctuates between 65%-74% with far more voting reviewers on audience score, with a 100% critic consensus in the latest season (of only 6 voting critics though).
Not that Google reviews is reliable in any sense of the word, but they tie at 4.7, despite Bluey having far more reviews.
Common Sense Media, 5/5 for Bluey on 117 “parental” and kid reviews and 113 kid reviews. MLP compares with 4/5 by 89 “parental” reviews and 307 kid reviews.
.
As for the “last seasons” ruining it, “The Last Problem” on IMDb is listed as one of the highest-ranking episodes for FiM.
Bluey has 318 reviews and 2 critics with a 9.4 score plus 15 wins and 8 nominations, and MLP has 212 reviews and 15 critics with a 7.7 score on 21 wins and 48 nominations (though bear in mind the length of time the show has aired). The top 2 episodes for Bluey average higher than that for MLP, if only slightly.
.
Overall, because of the lack of consistent reviews, Bluey just getting started and having fewer reviewers (depending), it’s difficult to really judge and compare. I mean, someone can just as easily invert the image’s context using Rotten Tomatoes.
I’ve not seen Bluey and I probably never will for a number of a reasons (including my unfair, sheer hatred for dogs). But I don’t doubt it’s probably a good show. Good enough to gloat on MLP? No.
I’m just glad they’re both beating out SpongeBob SquarePants on overall show average.
Oy, you alright there, mate? Lissen’, don’t you worry nothing, mate. You’ve had a good run! Enjoy your retirement!
Yet I never see the appeal with less 80% of them. And believe me, I already rewatched all of them. Some are better than I thought, I’ll give you that.
Edited
Sorry but you’re not changing my mind or minds of the target audience (and even their parents)
Well 20% are alright. 30% are bland. And yes, 50% of them are terrible.
Castle Sweet Castle, Tanks for the Memories, Appleoosa’s Most Wanted, Slice of Life, Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep, Canterlot Boutique, Rarity Investigates!, Crusaders of the Lost Mark, Scare Master, The Mane Attraction, The Crystalling, Applejack’s Day Off, The Times They Are a Changeling, Top Bolt, To Where and Back Again, All Bottled Up, A Royal Problem, The Perfect Pear, The Parent Map, The Beak Up Break Down, The Mean 6, A Matter of Principals, A Rockhoof and a Hard Place, Sounds of Silence, Frenemies, Student Counsel, Between Dark and Dawn, and The Last Laugh are terrible?
I dunno, the episodes became terrible since season 5
Well there’s your problem there