@Meanlucario
Well actually, hmmm….
I mean, in the real world, royal families married cousins all the time - that was the point. And Spike is considered at least semi-royal now, at least to the Crystal Empire. He’s at least somewhat honored.
@Ihhh
He likely wouldn’t have a family if that happened. At least not a proper one but this isn’t about him hatching on his own. He hatched because of her magic and that means she brought him into the world.
@northern haste
That’s doesn’t mean anything. Spike clearly doesn’t view Twilight as his mother, that’s why I don’t the idea of Twilight being Spike’s mother.
people this isn’t cannon, it’s just Cathy’s opinion.
BUT
No matter what anyone says, Spike just wouldn’t exist without Twilight. Heck he’s basicly the child of her magic cause without that he wouldn’t of been born. When it comes to the family tree and adoption, she would be his guardian but could possibly be labelled as mother.
She’s the closet thing he has to a mother. Even if he acts like she isn’t.
He defiantly looks like he would be her cousin more then Uncle so I’m happy with this!
@Background Pony #6BD7
Yeah, I was reading the comments and expected the same thing! Bet you thought at least the tired or fifth comment would be about it.
People are clouded by pony headcannons. The speculation has hidden the secret society right in front of our eyes. O-o
@MadVillan
I always assumed Twilight still called him a baby because she’s just unable to think of him any other way. My younger brother is 15, but I still refer to him as my baby brother. Then again, my brother is special needs, so he won’t ever really be “all grown up” in the traditional sense.
Well actually, hmmm….
I mean, in the real world, royal families married cousins all the time - that was the point. And Spike is considered at least semi-royal now, at least to the Crystal Empire. He’s at least somewhat honored.
Please let them age a bit first.
Me too.
Yep, I agree with that.
No, it implies Spike is more youthful and would be “more like a cousin”.
Genes don’t mean that much when the actual parent isn’t there.
The closest thing he’d have to a mother would still be his actual mother, the dragon who laid his egg.
Meh. Just tryin to prove a point. It’s all up to headcannon I guess.
you’re backpedaling.
He likely wouldn’t have a family if that happened. At least not a proper one but this isn’t about him hatching on his own. He hatched because of her magic and that means she brought him into the world.
That’s doesn’t mean anything. Spike clearly doesn’t view Twilight as his mother, that’s why I don’t the idea of Twilight being Spike’s mother.
Edited
So apparently dragon eggs don’t hatch on their own then? Ok….
BUT
No matter what anyone says, Spike just wouldn’t exist without Twilight. Heck he’s basicly the child of her magic cause without that he wouldn’t of been born. When it comes to the family tree and adoption, she would be his guardian but could possibly be labelled as mother.
She’s the closet thing he has to a mother. Even if he acts like she isn’t.
I haven’t forgotten that.
but spike being her cousin implies spike is in some way Twilight’s son.
Edited
Season 1: Winter Wrapup: Spike to Twilight: “YOU’RE not mommy…”
“As for the many instances of acting motherly I don’t recall that many, or really anything definitive at all.”
I feel like we are watching a completely different show…
@Background Pony #6BD7
Yeah, I was reading the comments and expected the same thing! Bet you thought at least the tired or fifth comment would be about it.
People are clouded by pony headcannons. The speculation has hidden the secret society right in front of our eyes. O-o
But…
IS ANYONE GONNA TALK ABOUT THAT PERSONS NAME AND PROFILE PICTURE? ANYONE?!
I always assumed Twilight still called him a baby because she’s just unable to think of him any other way. My younger brother is 15, but I still refer to him as my baby brother. Then again, my brother is special needs, so he won’t ever really be “all grown up” in the traditional sense.
I love her thoughts about this but there no need to be negative.you probably hate emberspike too.
all your theories and shippings are dead
Edited